New Zealand contractor EcoChill says retrofitting local dairy farms with the Eco2Dairy on-farm CO2 (R744) cooling and water heating system could reduce the country’s total emissions by 3.7% while also realizing significant operational savings for farmers.
EcoChill is a New Zealand-based commercial and industrial contracting business, which created Cold Energy Technology for the development of natural refrigerant-based refrigeration equipment; Cold Energy Technology owns and supplies the Eco2Dairy system.
According to Matthew Darby, Managing Director and Founder of EcoChill and Cold Energy Technology, using CO2 refrigeration in dairy farms is “Better for milk, better for the farmers and better for the planet.” Multiple retrofit case studies have shown significant savings in both direct and indirect emissions, as well as in refrigerant and system operating costs, Darby said.
Details of this system and its impact on the New Zealand dairy industry were presented by Darby during the State of the Industry – Australia and New Zealand (Part 2) online session on the second and final day of the ATMOsphere APAC Summit 2022 on June 28. The conference, which took place in person in Tokyo on June 27, was organized by ATMOsphere, publisher of R744.com.
“Better for milk, better for the farmers and better for the planet.”Matthew Darby, EcoChill
Dairy Industry Lags Behind
New Zealand’s economy is underpinned by its large dairy sector, explained Darby in his presentation. However, Darby realized in 2009 that this sector had not changed much in the previous 45 years. Approximately 65% of New Zealand’s on-farm refrigerant bank still comprises the high-GWP R404A refrigerant used with conventional direct expansion (DX) systems – even today.
About 14 years ago, a dairy farmer and friend of Darby’s approached him with a problem: the poor performance of his farm’s cooling equipment. Darby initially declined to get involved, but the persistent friend eventually swayed him into sitting down to discuss the challenges.
These challenges included:
- Cooling compliance – ever-changing regulations and requirements
- Emissions – global pressure to reduce carbon impact
- Refrigerant – HFC phase down threatening the refrigerants currently used by most dairy farmers
- Energy – need to reduce energy consumption for sustainability targets; also challenge with inconsistent power supply
- Costs – refrigeration makes up around 30% of the dairy farmers’ energy costs
As New Zealand is reliant on global supplies and imports of refrigerants, they are at risk of global price increases driven by the HFC phase down – regardless of the status of New Zealand’s own local phase down efforts. The local price of a carbon unit under the New Zealand Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS), is also driving “intolerable risk” as it has nearly tripled in the past two years. This has a huge impact on the cost of refrigerant, especially high GWP refrigerants like R404A.
In his presentation Darby shared that R404A is currently retailing for NZ$800 to NZ$900 (US$500–US$563; €492–€553), while CO2 has remained steady at only NZ$20/kg (US$27/lbs; €12.30/kg). Around a third of R404A price is due to the additional carbon unit cost. As a dairy farm typically needs a 20kg (44lbs) refrigerant charge, a farmer can expect to spend NZ$18,000 (US$11,667; €11,069) on the refrigerant alone.
“This is where cold energy come in,” said Darby in his presentation. “Our vision is to accelerate zero-carbon cooling naturally.” He realized EcoChill as contractor couldn’t solve the problem, and Cold Energy Technology was formed to eventually develop the “world-first,” patented ECO2Dairy product.
How does it work?
The ECO2Dairy system combines the two processes (heating and cooling) from traditional R404A DX systems into one. The CO2 system makes ice during off-peak times and uses this to cool the milk, delivering it into the vat at 2°C (36°F) only 20 seconds after leaving the cow. Additionally, this CO2 system also transfers its heat to the water, negating the need for electricity for hot water production. (See image below for full process detail.)
Case studies show significant savings
The first unit was installed in 2017 as a test on a farm in Waiuku, New Zealand, with 425 cows. Results from installing Eco2Dairy showed improved system performance and increased milk quality, said Darby. In the past five years since installation, the farmer has seen a 35% decrease in power consumption and a 61% reduction in total emissions, he added.
In 2021, Stalker Farm with a 600-cow herd also installed an ECO2Dairy system. Here, a very modern, three-year-old R404A system was replaced. Since the retrofit, the farm uses 32% less energy, he said, adding that the return on investment is estimated at only three years. Darby calculated that over the 15-year lifespan of the system, the farmer can expect to save NZ$439,000 ($274,877; €270,063) on energy and NZ$556,500 ($348,450; €342,347) on refrigerant (based on leakage rates of 15% per annum).
According to Darby’s calculations, retrofitting New Zealand’s dairy industry with ECO2Dairy (or a system of similar performance), could result in a 37% reduction of on-farm energy consumption. This would amount to an HFC usage reduction of 412,500kg (909,407lbs) and savings of 263,250 metric tons of CO2e per annum or 1% of New Zealand’s total energy production, meeting 3.7% of the country’s total emissions targets.
“This could be scaled up very quickly, and we’re not shy about introducing it globally,” said Darby. “The opportunities for this technology to be deployed quickly are huge.”
Watch the recording of this session where Stefan Jansen also presented on the efficiency of ammonia/NH3 (R717).
>>Read more R744-related stories from the ATMO APAC event.
Want to find out more, or have something to say about this story? Join the ATMO Connect network to meet and engage with like-minded stakeholders in the clean cooling and natural refrigerant arena.